Your Customer Moved On. Did Your Strategy?
BCG's survey of more than 13,000 consumers suggests demand is shifting faster than growth strategies, and a needs audit is one way to check which way yours is facing.

A large new survey suggests consumers are changing what they value faster than brands are changing what they promise, which makes this year’s planning round a good moment to ask which need your strategy was built to meet, and whether anyone still has it.
There is a slide that turns up in a lot of November planning meetings, and it sets out the brand’s positioning in four confident words, has survived at least two rebrands of the template, and somebody has updated the date in the corner without touching anything else. Nobody objects to it, because it was right when it was written and nobody has yet produced evidence that it is wrong, and so it goes into next year’s deck as the foundation on which everything else is built.
In August, Boston Consulting Group published research with a title that ought to make that slide a little uncomfortable: Global Consumers Have Moved On. Has Your Growth Strategy Caught Up? Its authors argue that “the preferences of today’s consumers are changing faster than most growth strategies can adapt”. The STAR Framework starts from motivation, from the need a person is trying to meet when they choose, and from that starting point, in a framing that is STAR’s own and has not been tested, a brand strategy is essentially a promise to meet a particular need. My interpretation, which is not a BCG finding and was not tested by its research, is that many brand strategies are still appealing to the need that drove the purchase two years ago, and that the slide with the freshly updated date is often where that shows. I looked at the same report in September, in BCG Asked 13,000 Shoppers Why They Won’t Buy, through the lens of why shoppers hold back; this piece picks up where that one stopped, with what the shift means for the strategy itself.
What BCG found
BCG’s Center for Customer Insight surveyed more than 13,000 consumers across 12 markets, including the UK, the US, China and India, supplemented the survey with more than 100 in-depth interviews and analysed more than 1,000 brands. From that it drew five themes which it describes as enduring and consumer-led rather than short-lived trends. On value, 67% of consumers said they would not buy a product they could afford if they did not perceive strong value, and BCG concludes that price decides whether a product is considered while value decides whether it is bought, yet only 14% of the brands it analysed consistently win on value. On longevity, nearly three-quarters ranked health and well-being as the strongest indicator of prosperity, well ahead of career at 40% and financial wealth at 28%. On solo living, 30% of households in mature markets now consist of one person, up six percentage points since 2010, and BCG reports that consumers associate living alone with “control, peace, and independence”, while between 50% and 70% of solo householders said products and services were not designed for people like them.
The last two themes concern trust and AI, and in my view they are the ones most likely to change how a strategy reaches anyone at all. Some 43% said they felt mentally overwhelmed by information, more than half said they did not fully trust any single source, and trust was concentrating on experts, friends and family and AI tools, none of which a brand controls. Meanwhile 31% said they used AI at some point in their purchase journeys, roughly triple the level BCG reports for 18 months earlier, and BCG reports that AI introduced consumers to brands they would not otherwise have considered in roughly 63% of AI-assisted journeys, which BCG frames, for incumbents, as the threat of “a recommendation that they never saw coming”. These are mostly survey responses, alongside BCG’s brand analysis and its own synthesis, and the direction echoes Kate Hardcastle’s six forces for 2026, an opinion piece she wrote as a Forbes contributor in January rather than research, which included personalisation that explains itself, value defined by confidence, and proof over promise. In her reading, nearly every major insight framework points to the same dynamic: people “want progress, but they want it to feel like choice, not coercion.”
Reading the shift as needs
Self-Determination Theory, as Richard Ryan and Edward Deci describe it, identifies three basic psychological needs: autonomy, competence and relatedness. STAR adds security as a fourth category of its own, and that addition belongs to STAR, not to SDT. Reading BCG’s themes through those needs is my interpretation and not something BCG measured, and STAR’s part in it is untested. The words BCG uses for how consumers describe solo living, control and independence, sound a great deal like autonomy. Feeling overwhelmed by information and narrowing trust to a few sources sounds like a strain on competence, the sense of being able to decide well, and the shift towards friends and family points to relatedness. Value judged as confidence that a purchase will do what it promises, as Hardcastle puts it, sits close to STAR’s security category.
If that reading is right, a brand can go on meeting a need perfectly well while many of its customers have quietly moved on to another. A family-sized multipack promising abundance meets a need, though perhaps not the one held by a customer buying for one, and a discount-led message promising savings meets a need, though perhaps not the one held by a customer who now asks, in BCG’s phrase, “Is this worth paying for?”
What’s the STORY?
STAR’s STORY method is one way to structure this kind of planning conversation, though it is an applied design rather than a tested method. It is the sensemaking layer of the STAR Operating System, used before deciding how to respond or communicate, and the letters stand for Situation (what is true now?), Trends (what is changing, repeating or diverging?), Observations (what do the signals allow us to notice or reasonably infer?), Relevance (why does this belong to the goal, audience, system or decision at hand?) and Why it matters (what is the central implication?). Its purpose is to separate evidence from interpretation before anyone writes a positioning line, and it does not replace evidence.
Applied to the slide, STORY asks you to describe the Situation as your own data shows it, not as it was described in 2024, to name the Trends affecting your category, perhaps drawing on BCG’s five themes where they apply, and to list the Observations that support each one, such as basket sizes, review language and the questions customers put to your service team. Relevance then asks which of those changes touch the need your brand was built around, and Why it matters forces a single sentence on what follows for next year. My expectation, which has not been tested, is that a team that completes all five honestly will find out whether the slide in the corner still describes anyone.
Two lenses, used on purpose
Regulatory Focus Theory may help explain, in my reading, why that conversation is often harder than it should be. E. Tory Higgins distinguished a promotion focus, concerned with accomplishments and aspirations, from a prevention focus, concerned with safety and responsibilities, and STAR’s type-level framing links the Realist lens with prevention and the Adventurer lens with promotion. That mapping is STAR’s own and was not tested by any of the research here. In STAR’s framing, the Realist lens foregrounds security, stability and reliability, along with simplicity and ease, and through it, on my untested reading, the old strategy looks like the safe choice, because changing a positioning that has worked feels like a risk to take on. The Adventurer lens foregrounds autonomy, exploration and freedom to act, and through it every new signal looks like an opportunity, which is one way a brand can end up chasing five themes at once and convincing none of its customers.
Neither lens describes a type of strategist, and nobody needs to be sorted into either, but the answer, in my reading, is deliberate lens switching: ask the Realist question of the new idea and the Adventurer question of the old strategy, so that each gets the scrutiny it would otherwise escape.
A toolkit for the needs audit
- Name the need you promised then. Write down, in one line, which need the current strategy was designed to meet, whether autonomy, competence, relatedness or STAR’s security, and what evidence it rested on at the time.
- Name the need that drives the decision now. Use your own customers’ evidence, gathered through STORY, rather than BCG’s global averages, which describe twelve markets and not your category.
- Put a number on the gap each quarter. Estimate what a mismatch would cost if it is real, whether in lost consideration, lapsed customers or margin spent on discounts to customers who wanted value, and review the estimate quarterly instead of annually.
- Switch lenses deliberately. Ask what the new idea puts at risk, then ask what the old strategy is failing to reach, and write both answers into the plan.
- Check what the machines say about you. BCG asks whether consumers and AI can independently verify the reasons to choose your brand, and asking an AI assistant to explain your brand’s offer is a quick, rough check of whether the promise has travelled, since answers vary by tool and by prompt.
The test question for the planning round is simple enough to ask out loud: which need would our customer say we meet today?
The slide with the four confident words will probably make it into next year’s deck, and it may even deserve to, but it should get there on fresh evidence rather than on a changed date. Customers rarely announce that they have moved on; they simply start to need something else, and the strategy only notices when someone asks.
If you would like to see which Mindsets tend to lead for you, the STAR Cognitive Profile Assessment at starassess.com takes 33 questions, and the assessment and its full report are both free, which may be a useful prompt for reflection. It does not predict how you plan, and the lens switching above applies whatever it shows.
David Chadderton is a behavioural strategist, Chief Marketing Officer and STAR Dynamics. He writes The Unoptimised Human.
References
Bharadwaj, A., Taylor, L., Barrios, G., Sanghi, K., Malby, A., Barton, C., Ariav, Y., Gell, J., & Portera, T. (2026, 26 August). Global Consumers Have Moved On. Has Your Growth Strategy Caught Up? Boston Consulting Group. See also the accompanying press release.
Chadderton, D. (2026, 21 September). BCG Asked 13,000 Shoppers Why They Won’t Buy. Kahneman, Higgins, and Deci Already Knew.. davidchadderton.com.
Chadderton, D. (2026, 7 September). What’s the STORY? The question that stops you diving. davidchadderton.com.
Hardcastle, K. (2026, 2 January). 6 forces shaping consumer behavior in 2026 and what they mean for business. Forbes.
Higgins, E. T. (1997). Beyond pleasure and pain. American Psychologist, 52(12), 1280–1300.
Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78.
Eight minutes. Thirty-three questions.
A precise picture of how you operate: motivations, decision style, and blind spots. Free to start.
- S
- T
- A
- R
The canonical source.
Essays, when there is something worth sending. Choose the subjects you want. I will ask you to confirm the address before I write.